People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Best bagels around. Love the twisty bagels here. So yummy. The staff is always friendly. The man in the back makes the best bagels. Highly recommend. ”
“ Great bagel place, take out only. Hard working staff, great breakfast and lunch food on the go. Prices are reasonable. Lots of cream cheese flavor options. Easy to miss in between market squares, but gem of a find. Friendly cozy atmosphere . We got everything bagel and onion bagel breakfast sandwiches. Both delicious! ”
“ Ordered 1/2 dozen bagels and cream cheese. I was skeptical because of the reviews and I hadn't experienced what it was like with previous owners. Being disappointed from bagel places often this was surprisingly a good experience. The bagels were fresh, warm, and the perfect texture. Not hard, overly chewy, or lacking any of the NY bagel feel. Cream cheese has also been an issue at other bagel places, where you know they aren't making their own or just don't get that it's supposed to be creamy and fluffy. This cream cheese was creamy and fluffy and not disappointing. ”
“ The bagel twists are fantastic, better than anywhere. Since they run out of them too early EVERY DAY, and turn away so many customers disappointed, why not make more? Also, whitefish and other fish are advertised as "also avail in 1/2, 1lb, 2lb sizes" That implies breakpoint pricing. When someone orders 2 lbs, dont charge them the 1/4 lb rate eight times over. In summary, great food, but they need to anticipate needs better and price the large fish orders fairly. Oy! ”
“ I remember going to this bagel store when I was in High School (back in the '80's). Every time I visit my dad here on Long Island, I stop here to bring a bag of bagels home. The store hasn't changed much. I bought an assortment of bagels to take back to Florida and one to eat now. They have all sorts of bagels and different flavored cream cheese along with self serve coffee & tea. Two thumbs up..... I'll be back next time I'm up this way. ”
Menu
Grilled or Fried Tilapia
$7.99Lux Sample Menu
$6.39Tuna Fish Sandwich
$5.39Backed Salmon
$5.39White Fish
$5.39
About
Bagel Patch
Welcome to Bagel Patch, a hidden gem located at 705 Medford Ave ste a, East Patchogue, NY 11772. This warm and friendly eatery specializes in delicious bagels, with a menu that showcases a delightful array of options that will satisfy your cravings any time of the day.
At Bagel Patch, the bagels are not just a menu item; they’re an experience. Customers rave about the twisty bagels and their remarkable freshness—each bite reveals a perfect balance of flavor and texture. As Gino O. puts it, 'Best bagels around. The staff is always friendly.' It’s clear that the welcoming atmosphere plays a vital role in making your visit memorable.
If you’re in the mood for something more than just bagels, Bagel Patch has a variety of popular items including:
- Grilled or Fried Tilapia - $7.99
- Tuna Fish Sandwich - $5.39
- Backed Salmon - $5.39
- Lux Sample Menu - $6.39
- White Fish - $5.39
One standout aspect of Bagel Patch is their commitment to quality. Vanessa A. highlighted that their cream cheese is, indeed, 'creamy and fluffy,' a notable improvement over many other establishments. The bagels boast a quintessential New York style that retains softness without being overly chewy—an essential quality for any true bagel lover.
The atmosphere, while primarily takeout, is cozy, making it a perfect spot for a quick breakfast or lunch on the go. Many customers like Sayeeda A. have noted the wide variety of cream cheese flavors that can elevate any bagel, whether it be for a breakfast sandwich or a simple snack. Popular choices include everything bagels and onion bagels, both evidently crafted with care and expertise.
However, it’s worth noting that given the popularity of their notorious bagel twists, customers are encouraged to arrive early, as these delectable offerings often run out fast. Brian B. calls for a better stocking strategy, reflecting a common sentiment in the bustling community that great food should be readily accessible.
In summary, Bagel Patch stands out not only for its exceptional bagels and sandwiches but also for its friendly service and community spirit. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and experience the authentic taste of what a New York bagel should be. You won’t be disappointed!
Book a table